Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Hazell's avatar

A thought provoking piece. One aspect of our industrial decline that is often overlooked is the lack of homegrown champions.

Don’t get me wrong fundamentals are crucial, and you aren’t going to get anywhere without competitive feedstock and energy prices, but nationality does matter.

Despite what The Economist and FT would have us believe people aren’t wholly rational even at Board level. Where you come from will influence your view of where to invest. I speak as an engineer who has worked for privately owned and listed British, German, Canadian, Australian, Italian, Danish etc. clients. Of course that inherent bias is explicit when it comes to state owned, or partly state owned companies.

I’m sure Sir Jim would love to invest more in the UK if we addressed those fundamentals but the fact is we have too few Sir Jims.

The City also plays its part.

Whilst in theory stock markets play a discipline role, ensuring capital moves to where it can be most efficiently employed, in practice once again that ignores human nature. Particularly with high capital cyclical businesses which like chemicals offer good long term returns. For these industries conglomeration provides protection against downturns in particular sectors in the short term. There are also physical and intellectual (knowledge and experience) synergies which help. Think of the large integrated European chemical hubs like Teesside, Rotterdam and Antwerp.

Unfortunately the City has the ‘attention span of a gnat’ and will always trade the prospect of long term gains for short term and often comparatively poor wins hence the examples you cite of shareholder driven break-ups.

Don’t get me started on the myopic nature of AIM listed or VC backed companies where all too often in my experience the entire focus is on ‘shareholder’ optics rather than building a viable business.

As an aside you might find these comments on the demise of ICI which I made on a post by Ed Conway at Material World of interest.

https://edconway.substack.com/p/a-dying-industry-dies-a-bit-more/comment/129487416?r=56zdk4&utm_medium=ios

No posts

Ready for more?